Scott Santens on Universal Basic Income, Automation and the Evidence

What this video is about
In this episode, writer and basic income advocate Scott Santens explains what an unconditional basic income actually is, and why he sees it as an investment in people rather than a welfare system that decides on their behalf what they need.
He came to it from automation in 2013, before the widely cited forecasts about how many jobs would be automated had entered the conversation. He goes through the objections directly: what the trial data shows about whether people actually work less, how a flat tax and a twelve thousand dollar basic income would land on different incomes, and what happens to prices.
About Scott Scott Santens is an American writer and advocate for universal basic income, based in New Orleans.
Jump to a moment
Full transcript
Read the whole transcript
Made automatically from the audio, so some words will be wrong. Tap a time to hear that part.
0:11and we are live Scotch is for coming on today Alex am in today how's everything been keeping on your end scares kit they say it's nice day over here in New Orleans so obviously people that don't know who you are some of my my followers might not know who you are I've heard of you tell us about your background than what you're an advocate for and how you got into sort of where you are sure so I am a writer and basic income advocate and so I write about it's a lot about the idea of an unconditional basic income which is essentially a an investment in people that is individual it's
1:00unconditional it's universal and it's in the form of cash that people can spend on anything away they want instead of you know a paternalistic kind of welfare system that decides what people need as if they know better than people I came into this through in automation perspective back in 2013 and this was before the report came out that I'm sure many people have heard of by now that in the next two decades about half of the jobs in the US will be automated and so it wasn't really part of the discussion yet at the time and it's become more the discussion since that but at the time
1:47really no one was was talking about the potential for heavy automation in the near future so this was a it was through actually reddit there was a discussion at the front page just about how quickly technology was advancing and how little people knew and understood what that meant and so that got me looking into this and you know thinking about the future and thinking about you know where we're going what our options are and that led me to this idea of a basic income and I at the time I had no idea had such a rich history I didn't know that we were almost passed a version
2:31under it of it under Nixon in the seventies I didn't know that that the us kind of led the way as far as experimenting with it in cities across the country and it even passed the Hat house proposed by Nixon and didn't make it through the Senate so we were really close and passing a version of it decades ago and I didn't even know that I thought that was fascinating piece of history and more you know that's that's more widely known now that the discussion is taking place again but Fassett I think how we didn't even really that like I didn't learn that in school and stuff and so you know I
3:06looked into the experiments around the world that we've actually done experiments other places that there was a full UVA experiment in Namibia and a fully BI experiment in India and that weird there's a lot that we know through unconditional cash transfer programs all across the world so there's just a there's a lot of rich evidence out there that I wasn't familiar with that I became familiar with and so uh yeah when I when I learned enough about this and as a moderator of the basin comes subreddit I also submit and find a lot of stuff and submit it and you know are the discussion there so I started
3:43writing about it and you know it's just hopefully I've done my part and it helping expand this discussion in people learning about this then and really kind of educating themselves and studying this topic in depth instead of just say reading you know one thing then along the way to actually crowdfunded my own basic income back in 2015 so since January of 2016 I've actually been starting every month with a thousand dollars via patreon and that's my floor so you know I'm capable and I'm able to earn anything on top of that but that's my floor or that's my minimum earnings per amount so I know that you
4:25know I got my food my rent covered that's covered and and so through that I've learned a lot about this as well it's just that you know a lot of this is about security it's a like this emotional sense of security that that once you get your basics covered you can really focus on the things that that matter energy oh yeah I mean it's a it's obviously an interesting concept and one the ice off is kind of the reason why I'm doing podcast and it's a guest to try and build my own sort of basic income to an extent through patreon I'm on there myself I get four dollars a month which
4:59doesn't really help for much but it's a you know if something canned it's better than nothing sigh and I appreciate the people that supported me but yeah I think it gives you that like you obviously if I was earning a thousand a month for more or five hundred pounds a month for 250 per month I think it's just extra cash and it's an extra bill that you don't have to go to work for or or doesn't come out of your bank and you think Jesus Christ so I pressure pressure pressure it kind of alleviates that stress which are by assumes yeah for the mental mental side of things
5:32yeah I think a really good way to look at this as Maslow's hierarchy of needs which is uh for anyone I'm familiar with so that's just that you know imagine like a pyramid where at the bottom are the absolute basics so like you need food in order to live you need shelter virtually you've got you've got to cover at these absolute most basics but then once those needs are met you don't just stop there and do you know nothing else you have higher needs so you know you have needs to to form community - you have social relationships to improve yourself as a person - to learn like
6:08there's a lot of other needs above that so once you cover those basic needs that's what you do and just having your basic needs met it's just amazing how different that is he yeah you're talking about less stress and just more ability to just focus on whatever it is is is most important to you which is not sitting around doing nothing nobody wants to do that no it's that I mean I think that's and we've got the basic income think a lot of people kind of assume that it's like a free right thing like people were just gonna get basic income or a universal basic income and they're just
6:44gonna be content with oh just sit on the sofa now I've got this money and I don't think it's everyone's aspirations I know there are like a small minority of people out there that probably would be quite content that way but I think is like humans were driven to want more yeah and also if this is based on a misunderstanding to you of how like the existing system works so you know the existing safety nets all over the world are are targeted what they mean is that you you only give assistance to somebody if say they're earning below a certain amount and so what when you do that
7:22that means that a once they earn enough then they no longer qualify for that assistance and then it's taken away from them so the result of that is that it's it it functions it's like a higher tax it's like a increased marginal tax rate because let's say you know if you're earning $10,000 and benefits and someone offers you a $10,000 job what we think is that that person should be have a new total of $20,000 right or at least it should be say fifteen thousand dollars or something but instead and they lose like the whole thing or even say more than the amount because the benefits were higher so you can go from say ten
8:08thousand dollars when benefits to you know ten thousand dollars with your job in which case what's the point because now you're working a job maybe you don't even like and of course it's it's it's hard it's hard work taking up a lot of time and you're no better off so why would you do that it makes more sense not to accept employment under those conditions and so that's the way the current system is built so the basic income just looks at this and says well that doesn't make any sense like work should reward you with additional income and so that's exactly what happens you because it's never
8:42taken away you always benefit by earning additional income so how would it work within society because obviously a lot of people kind of look it it's like it's a communist thing how could like I say there's always going to be people that are gonna also be like begrudge it all these people like I'm working and they get free ride and whatever and I think it's that negative aspects like they're not getting a free ride because you're also getting the money as well but I don't understand how it would like implement and work with like society in the economy yes so a couple things about that is it's the the universal aspect of
9:25it means that there's that there's no stigma there's no us and and then because everyone's getting it so if you're looking it's like the closest thing in the world to this operating in existence already is the Alaskan dividend which is existence since 1982 in Alaska which is obviously not a communist state and so everyone they air earns around run $1,000 on average per year since 1982 this is a just a straight up dividend everyone receives it rich or poor so oh it's hard to look at something like that and no one there looks at something like that as being like the handout or helping some people instead of other people and it's
10:05certainly not seen as communist or socialist also does everyone's getting it and it's cash so you get cash and you spend that in work it's you know that's that's capitalism you are you know it cash is how these markets work this is not supplying say free shirts and and free boxes of food and you know free services the government provides you know that's something that's more of like a socialistic model straight up cash is capitalistic model which is why you know you're well-known free-market economists like Milton Friedman and Friedrich Hayek both supported this idea of the non conditional basic income for that reason that they you know not in
10:51freedom and knew that that this would be good for markets it's good for capitalism and that you're able to to go about the what the state does in a way that decreases the size of the state and increases freedom you're reducing the ability to government to tell you what to do and you're able to have that agency yourself that freedom to make your own choices using the cash to yet so was the like you know like the technology aspect that he said we're I mean we're seeing it like in Tesco's in the UK we have like a lot of self-service scans and stuff like that which of course is no doubt led to
11:33people not being employed in less jobs that Tesco's need to create because obviously they've got self-service scanners and stuff like that it's that kind of law was that your major spark where he was like you know it'd be great idea for people to have this basic income as their safety as their floor as their safety now even if they lose their jobs they're still okay they're not like oh [ __ ] my mortgage is gone or whatever you're not I mean yeah yeah so it's not it's not all only that that things won't get bad with a basic income in light of automation it's that things can get so
12:11much better than they are now so and it's important to differentiate those two I feel because a lot of people like them they're coming across base can come through technological argument they think of it as like you know this kind of in case of emergency break glass kind of idea like like it's just things are gonna get really bad but they will won't get as bad as long as we have this and the thing that really got me into this idea and why I am such an advocate is I realized that it did it's not that it actually is a tool of making things just far better than they are now because
12:49yeah the the results of poverty around us are very expensive in a lot of ways you see worst health outcomes which cost a lot through the healthcare system you're looking at higher crime rates which wouldn't be there which is expensive and also hurts people and prevents them you know from reaching their potentials through you know imprisonment and that we're in these jobs that we don't necessarily want to be in that this is like an involuntary labor market that there's a coercion aspect of this because people don't have the freedom to say no to the labor market they they have to accept whatever wages are offered to them through employers which
13:31is very exploitative if you provide people the freedom to refuse to sell their labor then they have bargaining power and that means that they have eaten more equal footing with employers and they can say well I'm not gonna do that work under these conditions I'll do it for $20 an hour instead of $10 an hour or I'll do it for 15 hours a week instead of 40 hours a week you know that there's a lot more power and leverage involved for people once work becomes fully voluntary and so there's just a lot of aspects to this that kind of all add up that just the evidence points to things just being a lot better
14:16that you know people will be more engaged with their work that you know intrinsic motivation over extrinsic motivation there's a lot of factors involved how could this like because how would this like be sort of implemented into say poorer countries because obviously they I mean obviously this is more from a technological standpoint not with with if they had like the technology though say the UK and America have but how would it be working like poorer countries yes there's a really interesting paper that I would recommend and maybe can even link to it but at this video it was a paper by Gary Blauman oft called he was looking at the
15:01ability to apply the Alaska model to a resource poor state and I think that provides a really interesting blueprint how you could do this in poorer countries because poorer countries may be the poor and underdeveloped as far as like businesses and a consumer economy and things go but they can also be very rich in natural resources what they're doing is essentially letting companies come in and just take those resources for free and as usually because they politicians are you know being bought off and just you know doing what the companies want but say a poorer country could say you know we understand that the lithium buried in the dirt here
15:50is extremely valuable to you so if you want this natural resource then you need to pay us for it and what we're going to do is actually put at least a large portion of that revenue into a sovereign wealth fund like Alaska has like Norway has and then that sovereign wealth fund can be built up and pay dividends to everyone I'm there so you don't need to have like a heavy tax pace to be able to handle this you can't and just follow Alaska's model and instead of the way Alaska doesn't which is only oil there's a lot of other resources that you could look at including even you know land
16:30value itself and you know just just look at things that we commonly owned that not only is a natural resource but let's say you know the the airwaves itself you know this is companies should pay money to actually transmit through the airwaves that you know a carbon tax would actually make it but it apply a cost to polluting the air which is something that we all own so there's just a lot of ways we go about this kind of dividend model in other places and also in countries like say India so that's considered a more poor country the way they currently do things right now is through heavy subsidies so the
17:11government pays for a bunch of subsidies to make things cheaper so let's say you want to make grains cheaper and various food cheaper oil cheaper and things like that because then though those were poor can afford those things but another way of going about that is to just to eliminate those subsidies and actually provide that as cash to individuals to be able to afford higher costs there's your your base can come before you know countries like that which India is a actually probably in the next two years it's expected that they're all either that they'll start up some kind of large ubi pilot or say do like a small
17:53introduction like you know one of their states over there um it's mad cuz like it is slowly like a certain countries obviously I'll definitely looking into it and or at least something that's similar I don't understand like how it would work for say someone with I don't know three kids and someone with one they would they get this basic income and that it differs slightly from the current welfare state like obviously the welfare state takes into consideration someone's got free five whatever however many kids and you get that money how would this all have work with that situation yeah so that's interesting one of the one of the design aspects of it that I
18:41support is the fact of a child allowance component or a child of basic income so adults get the full basic amount and then those under 18 would get this partial amount because that's a like in the US the way that we classify poverty by household is say one person it's around $12,000 two-person household is 16 thousand three person is twenty thousand so in the u.s. way upper design it is that as an individual don't you get twelve thousand dollars per year and then for every kid it's four thousand dollars per year so that was that's how you scale it for the household and that's how a lot of these experiments
19:22have been run and you know that's how a lot of these things are being discussed as a detail that isn't say widely thought of but any any I think well-designed ubi should include that child component and if it's because actually a lot of countries already have a child allowance then say in those countries they don't have to actually implement that so they already have it they already are providing a essentially a child basic income like Canada or does that so when they are looking at a bass can come they don't have to worry about the child element just like they don't to worry about the senior element
19:58as well it's just like 18 to 64 but it's so another people hear about this and I think oh my gosh won't fertility rates just like go up because and you're having you're paying people to have kids and so okay so let's look at that and as the the existing system especially like in the u.s. we only essentially care about someone if they have kids so if you're in able-bodied single adult with no kids then you essentially get no assistance whatsoever it's when you when you have a kid that you suddenly get assistance and that can be a good amount of assistance through all the various programs that we have so a way of
20:42looking at it is that right now you get zero dollars and then if you have a kid you get twenty thousand dollars so that's a large incentive to have a kid if you're looking at it that way with a basic income you would have twelve thousand dollars right besides the other one was for two kids so the with the with a basic income you would start off with twelve thousand dollars and then you'd get $4,000 for a kid and another four thousand dollars for another kid so it the incentives are smaller than the existing system which goes from zero to twenty thousand for two kids or from
21:20zero to sixteen thousand for one kid so there's a there's a big incentive difference there but that's also more of just the way people think about these things the way that it sounds to what how things would work but that's not how actually things work you know the evidence says that this does not actually increase fertility rate it's giving an unconditional cash transfer like that and that's because these programs exist all over the world there's a lot of evidence for this it's not just you know a nun pregnant on a nun experimented with an idea we know that this does not actually increase for soli rates and we actually have seen
21:57decreases too and we also know in general that when you lift people out of poverty when you'd like decrease inequality the fertility rates go down so it's just a lot of like poorer countries you have a lot of kids for the same reason we did the same thing in the u.s. you know we needed help on the farm you needed you have to have that extra help as soon as you have enough money and there's no reason to do that kids are expensive you know you just don't want to like you know in the average in the u.s. your average expenditure for having a kid is around a quarter million dollars it's
22:32merely we run two hundred thousand dollars and that's that's a big investment you know and it's a a $4,000 per year amount does not equal that you know it just doesn't cover all that it's expensive deaf kids yeah I mean it's strange because people look at like this idea from kind of an in the box type of way when I think like the way you're talking to me now and like given these ideas of like $4,000 per kid it's like just thinking outside of the box like that's a [ __ ] good idea and then when they become an adult obviously so for it for instance myself from 26 years old to
23:19still live at home with my mum obviously if I had this basic income my now I'm an adult I'd be on a higher wage which means obviously I could provide more in the home or I could save for myself some money and then move out and get my own property without having to do a shitty job that you know you don't enjoy to save and so on so I think it's a great light when you word it like when you put it that way and when you start thinking outside of the box I think you start to realize this not a bad idea at all the only sort of mindset where I keep
23:55because I was speaking to my girlfriend beforehand about it she said where does the money come from oh sure it's very common question like she's like the government here hasn't got money to even put into our NHS but yet they can bomb Syria or whatever which cost us 200 sign called Midianites I and I've tried saying well that money could have been spent on our seventy-five million or eighty million in the population we could have each you know yes the money certainly exists you know it's that it's that true it's not accurate to say that the money doesn't exist it is politically difficult you know to to get at money depending on
24:35what you're looking to do with it so one of the really interesting things about basic income is is that it's not left or right it has support from both conservatives and liberals you know throughout history Milton Friedman supported it was their King jr. supported it you know to this day you've got major business executives supporting it you've got unions supporting it like how many ideas is that true for like hardly hardly anything it's rare so that's one aspect of this that says that you know we can have the there the ability to politically do this to get out that money so where is the actual money coming from well so again you're
25:18looking at the existing system and it's important to convert the existing system over to a basic income you know we already have a lot of welfare programs that wouldn't make sense to have alongside a basic income you also you would incorporate that into it but also there's there's welfare programs that we don't see as welfare that's targeted towards the middle and even upper classes and those actually are provided through tax systems so those are a tax craft and it's tax allowances and deductions and subsidies you know it's why are we giving thirty thousand dollars to a billionaire to help them afford a bigger mansion like that doesn't make any sense as far as so if
25:59this welfare system goes so what would make sense to eliminate those allowances and expenditures and loopholes as well as part of this as to replace that with a basic income so instead of a billionaire getting a thirty thousand dollar tax credit they beget a $12,000 basic income which would effectively reduce you know from their taxes but in a decreased way so it's important to reform the system and when it comes to additional taxes or additional revenue sources there's just a lot of options and I think that's an important discussion to have and the answers to that will vary from country to country depending on what it suits them best in the US I
26:45really like the idea of a of a land value tax because then you're not taxing income you're taxing the actual unimproved value of land this is a Henry George's idea that also even note in the Friedman to thought that was the the best possible tax that you could do because usually when you tax something you you decrease it you know you get less of it but you can't get less land it's it's always there and what you do by taxing it is actually incentivize its development and because that's the that's also differencing the land value tax and property tax you with the land value tax you're taxing the land and
27:25self not what's built on it so you're encouraged to build on it to maximize the earnings potential that you can get because you're being charged or rent on it so imagine say like a skyscraper next to a vacant lot they would both pay the same tax the way the the person owning the vacant lot it would make sense to either develop it into a skyscraper or to sell it to someone who would take it would make use of that land in a way that they could pay the rent on it and instead that rent going towards government to decide what to do with it you would use that to provide this basic
28:02income to everybody and that only makes sense because they're actually the ones creating the value of the land you know imagine like a piece of empty land in the desert and you own that it's worth nothing and you sit on it and then suddenly a city is built around it so you've got all these people coming in and they build all this infrastructure and people live in there and they build up these houses suddenly that that worthless piece of land becomes you know say you could sell it for millions of dollars well what did you do to do that it's you didn't do anything he didn't lift a finger all that value was created
28:40by everyone around you it's collective value generation so it only makes sense to apply like a land value tax to paying a big income because it recognizes that the money actually belongs to everybody because they created the value and it should go back to people so that's one one mechanism that I really like for this another one is is again looking at you know taxing things in a way that we want to tax things we don't want so carbon taxes I think it makes sense for a basic income as well because that what you're doing is saying we don't want to pollute the air with a lot of greenhouse gases
29:16that are accelerating climate change we want to reduce that so you make it more expensive to pollute via a fee per ton of co2 emissions and when you do that then and when it's paired with a basic income then you create these choices so yes stuff costs more and so therefore it it'll cost more to have your the carbon footprint that you currently have so what you can do is you can use the money to me contain the carbon footprint or you can actually pocket the money and decrease the size of your carbon footprint so you can use that money on other things and so if you do it that
29:55way then you're looking at better competition between say green companies and ideas and just the whole green industry versus the fossil fuel industry because right now fossil fuel industry is enjoying a reduced cost due to the externalization of costs you know they're not paying for the full costs of fossil fuels it's it's artificially cheap so it just makes sense to actually make this more expensive for them to pollute to kind of equal the playing field in a way that should exist already you're reducing those eternal relations so it's also a free-market approach as well you're you're providing money and it helps green businesses to grow through people deciding that that's the
30:42way that we should go so that's another funding method that I like to choose as well and also I like the idea of like a value-added tax like a consumption tax because then what you're doing is it has a this a natural clawback mechanism to it and you're also not taxing income you're taxing consumption so you're not you know you're not hurt from from from working from earning income it's not reduced it's you have the choice of buying something or not buying something it's an indirect tax and the way that that would work so let's say it's let's say it's a 10% tax and a $12,000 basic income if you're
31:27looking at that way then for every one I'm spending more than $120,000 per year they would be a net payor because it their taxes would go up over $120,000 and then they would be they would be receiving this $12,000 basic income to cover the 10% part and then everyone earning less than $20,000 would be or spending less than on $20,000 per year it would be in that receiver so you'd see that's actually a very progressive tax and therefore the basic income is not it's going to those who are spending more than hundred thousand dollars but they aren't nap and offici Ares Brewers is at the bottom of the middle everyone
32:10is a net beneficiary so that's another text I think makes sense in combination with a basic income so it's things like that financial transaction taxes I think also makes sense and also something that's really interesting to me is is sovereign money and so this is this idea where it looks at the way that money exists right now how we created and money is created out of debt by banks that's really where most of the money it comes from a lot of people don't understand and I don't know that so sovereign money throughs through señores reform would say that well why are we letting banks benefit from the creation
32:52of money let's prohibit banks from creating money and instead create it ourselves the best way to create money in the most fair way to create money is to actually create that money in the hands of everyone universally individually and equally so like in the US based on the existing amount of money creation you could create new money at the same rate as so therefore you wouldn't create like heavy inflation any more than you have now it would have the same inflation you wouldn't you would create say two hundred dollars per month in everyone's accounts universally and so that's not tax money it's just created money it's just not letting banks to it and
33:37actually creating it in a way that makes more sense and so if you do that then of course you only need a fraction of what you have to raise to cover because it's already covering some of it through actual money creation so you know all those the ideas make sense to me and there's a lot of other options and stuff you know country to country and if one thing like what would the what would stop say companies increase in their prices of food clothing you know just normal materials because of this thing they know that there's this universal basic income now so for instance obviously we have a living wage that
34:21we're currently on per hour that we get paid and obviously the you know it's based on the pricing of everything here obviously if this universal basic income come in and people to work in will stop in corporations don't jar we're just gonna shoot our prices up because we know if people can't afford it yeah so that's another common response to hearing about a basic income and so yeah that's an interesting conversation to and there's a there's actually a lot of variables to the inflation equation so if we get under that bed so we recovered that that the idea basic income isn't about same monetary expansion it's actually like a fiscal measure through
35:01tax and transfer and then even when you do the disovered money idea you're still not expanding the money supply greater than it is now so that's typically a like a lot where a fear from inflation comes from through rising costs it's just that you have you have more people at the bottom in middle having more money and you'd have people at the top having less money and so it's the same amount of money now another element of this is that you still have competition so let's say you own a business and you know that everybody has a basic income now so you're gonna raise all the prices in
35:38your business by say 10 percent or something so say hey they've got more money I'm gonna take more of that well then you have like an Amazon in Amazon's like I understand that people want to pay less so not only am I not going to raise prices but I'm going to lower them because I want to take that business so suddenly all those people who are greedy and we thought they could do that they go out of business and they're taken over they're destroyed by the Amazons of the world who actually understand that people want to pay less not more in effect there's an example of this
36:13actually in Alaska every year so every year its distributed around the same time everyone gets their dividend check at around the same time so businesses know that Alaskans have more money at that time what do they do there's actually sales everywhere because everyone is competing against each other in order to try to get that money to be spent at their business versus a competing business so it's the other one of those things where it sounds like that might be something you would want to do but in reality it's a terrible idea to actually raise your prices like that so another element of this is that when it comes to rising prices and
36:50increased demand and supply wants to meet that demand you know if you're a business you don't want to run out of product you want to supply as much as that product as you can that people are buying so when it comes to raising prices if the we the question is is the supply variable can you increase supply and to what degree if you can't do if you can't increase the supply to meet demand you're gonna have to raise prices if you can increase apply you're gonna want to keep prices the same or even lower them and if you can dramatically increase supply then prices actually go down so an example of this and we've
37:28seen this as well in ubi experiments so as a to portray this imagine imagine a village where eggs are really expensive they cost like $1 per egg it's like because there's just hardly any eggs everyone starts getting a basic income so you would think that now you could charge more for eggs but what people do is they buy chickens because they're like oh I want cheap eggs so they buy a chicken and all of a sudden you have all these chickens in this village and they're making a lot of eggs so now all of a sudden there's a ton of eggs in this village the prices of eggs go way down because
38:03there's such a huge supply of it so that's another it's a it's a good illustration of how increased demand can actually read actually lead to such increase in supply the prices go down instead of up what you're looking at for increased prices that's a realistic outcome of basic income is kind of your your luxury items you know it's like let's say you have let's say you're someone on Etsy and you're selling handmade purses that are you make yourself they're entirely unique you can't really make move or than what you're already making you you want to but you're limited you can only make say you know one a week in order to meet the
38:47demand so in that case you could charge more because you'd have a lot more customers wanting that one purse and you could say well because there's such demand for this and I can't make any more then I'm gonna raise the price and so that's an example of where you can see raise prices but for a lot of the goods and services that we see around us right now you wouldn't see price increases and you could even see price decreases yeah I mean obviously just looking it from the way like hearing it from your perspective changes the full process straightaway I think a lot of people come in with that negative frame
39:24of mind about a basic income like oh well people who don't want to work there they're getting free money and then like my question there well we've got more money so corporations are just gonna want to take more money from our side and then when you're worried like that and think well if they did increase their prices and company would decrease their prices and end up failing as a business they can't take that risk so they actually have to decrease the prices it works what are your views on crypto currencies because obviously Bitcoin shut up loads and now it's kind of drops I don't know what's that now
40:02I've got him but I was invested in it for a while and my money's still in there at the moment I've just let go back down because I didn't put much in but what's your view on sort of and take on the cryptocurrency world as it is at the moment you think it's dead unburied or no no actually I I firmly believe that that blockchain technology represents the kind of level of change as far as the internet goes so I think what we're looking at right now is potentially like a internet bubble burst part two where the result of this is there's a lot of exuberance and a lot of
40:42just excitement on this new technology and people starting up things without a real business model for profitability and success and you know now there's big bubble forms and it it bursts and then the result of this is that going forward the technology is still there and it still works it's just it's more important to figure out like businesses and ideas that do actually have profitability and actually work for their own reasons so you know imagine looking back in the day with the dot-com bubble burst and looking at a company like Amazon which i think is kind of like potentially like Bitcoin as far as this you know like oh well that's not
41:23gonna work because the internet just didn't work and you know it's it's just not gonna happen but investors in Amazon but back then of course have been right to have done so looking back that you can see this huge growth it's a very successful model when it comes a Bitcoin I think that it's still going to go back up and you know I think other other coins it could fall in popularity to another coin that overtakes it I think we'll see other block chain technologies and other coins be quite successful going towards the you know in the future and also it's its own form of automation - that's a lot of
42:08potential there because you can algorithmically replace a lot of these middlemen that don't need to exist you can use blockchain technology to make things was much more efficient and by efficient we mean fewer people necessary in which case that increases this unemployment aspect and I think that's actually a great thing we if a middleman should not exist then yeah automate them out of the process as get rid of them used to use blockchain technology to decentralize this and you know just enable people to to do things directly and without these middlemen and also I really just like the ability through decentralization to say create these currencies in a in a way that's that
43:01makes more sense again through I think the best way to create currency is through everybody's you know individually universally so you've got coins like mana which is like a ubi currency where everyone receives their share of this newly created currency you know on a weekly basis so that's like the currency is being created at the bottom and because everyone has access to it then they can use that and I think that makes a lot of sense and also I think makes a lot of sense as companies to apply like these kind of dividend models so imagine how different things would be if if Facebook instead of having a model where all the revenue
43:45accrues to stockholders actually recognize that most of value was being created by its users you know everyone is essentially doing work on Facebook it's just it's been that kind of atomized it's it's you don't think of something as work when you spend say one second writing a status update you're liking something or or putting a smiley face or sharing something but it's work it's it's obviously it's it's just there's it's really really small but it's it's shared among you know two billion people around the world for Facebook and so there's a lot of value being generated but the users themselves they're just being told that your reward is a free service can you
44:31can you imagine does that make any sense can you imagine the the stockholders of Facebook being told hey thank you for investing in us your reward is that you get to use Facebook like no that's that's not how it works it only makes sense to actually provide a dividend to the was creating the value and so with blockchain technology it's more it's you're more capable of say creating these kind of dividends where you reward people like on Steam it I think is a good example is the platform where people are were actually yeah the you earn coins essentially for voting stuff up and and for creating content and those coins
45:17aren't necessarily worth anything except they are in the marketplace and so they are actually earning a share of this essentially all the users of steam it are like the stockholders of steam it especially those who are you know keeping actual steam power and it's like an investment so it's really interesting to look at the way that these can all combine because you can imagine the future where there's a lot of platforms out there placed based on blockchain technology where people are earning some kind of cryptocurrency dividend or something through their use of of their say a Facebook clone and a Twitter clone and a retic clone and let's say their
46:02use of like there's self-driving cars or whatever you're getting your data dividend so you can imagine like a lot of sources combining together to increase everybody's income above you know what they would be with or without a basic income so with the basic income work with a block shame like in the sense of paying everyone out or whatever say the banks were you know it was all decentralized the banks of [ __ ] they're done for no one's using proper money anymore everyone's converted over to the block it's a perfect world how would the universal income sort of what without would it be one coin that is converted
46:44into other coins or what did we pay back yeah it's a it's a good question and you know it certainly there's it can go in go either way it can go both ways you can you can imagine like a ubi platform built on say the etherion blockchain so let's say etherium itself doesn't create new currency in the hands of people but then someone creates a platform built on aetherium that does do that and it's really popular with all etherium users so essentially all etherium users get this income through another platform you know through a coin built on that so that you know that's that's one way of going
47:31about it or you could have I actually think that that the ability to actually create these dividend stream as for people is actually going to be seen as a competitive advantage at some point as we go forward and because why would you use a platform that doesn't pay you versus a platform that does pay you as long as the user base is equivalent you know why would you use a complain that you aren't given versus a coin that you are given all things all else being equal so if there's there's already multiple coins out there that are being provided to everyone individually let's say you know Swift demand is another one
48:16it's not on the blockchain yet it's in ICO at the moment but people are already receiving the swift's on a regular on a daily basis actually and it's not on the blockchain right now but it will be and then there's other coins you know solid are and dinna turn circles a lot of ideas out there as far as applying ubi to cryptocurrency and I think those will will be successful and I think that when it comes to other platforms comparing the two you like say a steam it versus imagine like another like steam it but doesn't actually pay its users why would you use the other one
49:00unless like the user base was a lot bigger I think you've got a competitive advantage by actually making sure that people the user basis is valued and seen as having value it's kind of like creating a Facebook 2.0 and then paying people yeah saying come over to Facebook 2.0 we will pay you for every post you put up and every time someone likes your status we're gonna pay you for that as well and that's and then they have like a billion two billion people using it and before you know it you're rolling around in cash yeah I think that's C I think that's the only realistic way of
49:39actually getting around and the first mover advantage from these ginormous platforms that have huge user base this is you know the the one big difference is that that they don't reward their users so if you can reward your users and provide a similar experience and grow the network to a point where the size the network itself is competitive against these existing platforms you could succeed in winning people over to your new platform whereas right now it's extremely difficult to do that otherwise because why would you go from Facebook to a competitor Facebook we're just the same thing it's just maybe you don't want to be in Facebook anymore because
50:24you're angry about how they mishandled your data but yeah the way to win them over is to not only handle it right but actually to reward them and not my sort of last question really is how can you be I help better match people to jobs how can it yeah I think that's a really a real powerful component and again there's evidence behind it so like all of this the one of the reasons one of the main reasons why I got so big into basic income is because I really I seek out evidence I care about what's real and what isn't you know I don't just like things
51:03because it sounds right I have to look into it and the evidence is just really solid for a basic income so as another example of this one of the results of the negative income tax experiments in the 70s was you know people will look at that if you just look at the let's say a conclusion and say oh well work decreased say you know 5% or 8% for primary earners and so oh my gosh that's great busy that people worked 8% less but you have to look at this you have a look at the details and so the details show that people didn't actually reduce their amount of hours what they did is they
51:51actually spent more time primary earner spent more time between job was looking for the next job so the result of that is that if you look at a year or their hours went down because there was a greater amount of time between jobs but that's a better fit you know you you don't want a system where people are accepting the first job that comes their way because they have no other choice but to accept it that's how you create bad fits that that's how you have unproductive employees you know if you're if you're not doing a job that you care about you're unproductive you're disengaged what you want is for people to find the
52:29job that's right for that and that means earning a sufficient amount of money that means having the hours that you prefer in the benefits in the environment that you prefer you you want people to have to be choosing their jobs and so you actually did see that as a result you know one of the one of the biggest problems I feel in the this is a global problem - that globally only 15% of workers are engaged by the work that they do everyone else is either actively disengaged or not engaged that's not good for productivity in the u.s. it's slightly better than that it's a third of people are engaged by what they do so
53:15two thirds are not engaged or actively disengaged which means you know your city you're taking up a chair and there's even so there's there's people outside of the labor market and people wanting a job and they can't find one because someone is sitting in the chair who does not give a [ __ ] about the job that they're doing because they're just doing it because they need the income they may hate their jobs they hate their bosses they hate their work they don't want to be there they want to be doing something else they don't want to just be sitting at home - nothing they like want to start up their own business they
53:49they want to find the work that that that is their passion you know that's what drives people so what we want to do is create a situation to create an environment to create a system that enables people to to match to the jobs to choose the jobs that do engage them so I think I think an unconditional basic income would dramatically increase that engagement rate because people would be choosing jobs instead of being coerced into them and there's also evidence for this - there's an experiment that was done looking at engagement in tasks and when what they did is they put people in a room and they said okay here's what here's this
54:34task and here's this task choose one or the other and and we'll be back later so they come back and those people on average spent five minutes doing those tasks so in another condition they had the exact same tasks and they said okay can have this task we have this task or there's a third option you can just sit here and do nothing and then we'll be back later and check things out so in that condition where they had this third option to do nothing the people worked on average 7 minutes per task they were more engaged in the tasks that they could say no to doing why well
55:18that's an interesting psychological element because you're thinking that that if you have the ability to not do something then obviously it's voluntary and so you're choosing to do it and you're choosing to do it because you want to do it you're more engaged if you have no choice then you don't care about it yeah so you're not as engaged so it's interesting that's just another element of evidence that's built into this saying that we can increase engagement we can increase productivity actually making sure that people have the option to say no yeah I mean I figured to see also an increase in the quality of work people yeah from people who are
56:02passionate about it say for example I work in the fitness industry obviously say there's someone in the fitness industry that doesn't want to do that job and there's someone who can't get that job because that person like you said sitting in the seat a lot of people is that they're seeing people that they're speaking to within that gym based environment aren't getting the results that they require which it could be I don't know them but they want to lose to stone and the person there's just so ya don't really care like yeah sure right so much some shitty program you know and then they they never lose
56:34the way they you know they don't have a personal trainer that pushes them and just because that person doesn't want to be in that job and you know we could go on about the effects that that could potentially have whereas if you gave that job to someone who wanted to do that obviously that person would lose the way and then the implications of them not losing the way or whatever would never unfold so it's definitely an interest in that the better way to look at it really is if you obviously had that because I agree with you we don't really have at this current moment that free will to go and do what we want to
57:08do yeah yeah as well as even your own business you know yeah yeah that's what I was gonna go next is self-employment is such a good example where I think there's a lot of people out there in that don't want to be there they actually want to create their own jobs that want to start a business and again this is through the evidence there's a huge entrepreneurship effect everywhere unconditional cash transfers and basic income have been try and so in me BIA self-employment jumped up three hundred one percent and in India trial villages or where it was tried were three times more likely to start a business than
57:50control villages yeah this is seen over and over again where you see that people choose to actually start throw festus into self-employed instead of selling their labor to others doing something that they don't want to do and again lucky when it comes to like your your your example for fitness like if you if you own your own business and you use your own person you want to you know to provide the best you know service that you can you want people to be you know bragging about you and going oh you want a good trainer this person will just rock your world they are like really good and so you you're doing something
58:31because it's you own it you're you your own person it's important to you to be the best and you care a lot about that if you're working for someone else a lot of times you don't care it's their mission there are the ones profiting from it it doesn't benefit you it's not you as an individual so that's it's a big it's a different dynamic and also just look at like the arts itself to you know if you're like even like a YouTube is a good an example you've got people creating videos for clicks hoping that you get that that ad revenue and so there may be the they themselves have an
59:11idea that they want not to do but they don't think that that will have as many clicks they think it'll be better they think will be more informative or more truthful or you know more interesting or maybe it'll be longer and so sort or whatever but as long as you need an income in order to survive and you need that advertising revenue you're gonna be focused more on what sells you know what can I and get people to click this with so again it goes to as well aside from engagement it's just just that you know as long as people are driven with this basic need for for
59:49survival then yeah there's a big quality issue there you know just imagine a world where people are creating the content that really they feel almost passionate about because they don't need the income they actually are fine creating stuff for free in fact they even enjoy it more like I even have experienced that myself by having a basic income I prefer more people to be able to say read something that I've written so why would I put a behind a paywall yeah I could earn more money for doing that but then it's possible I wouldn't even own the rights for it I've done that before where I sold an article
1:00:28and it's weird that to this day I have to ask them for for permission to republish it and somewhere so I wrote it why why isn't it mine well because I got money for it and I signed a contract whereas if I publish something for free out in the Creative Commons then I had welcome people and say hey publish this anywhere you want to just apply the same license to with the share alike and say you know just say Scott satins wrote this here it is then you know publish it ever really want to the more people who read what I've written the happier I am because that's why I wrote it I wrote it
1:01:04so that people could read it and it could reach as many minds as possible that's what makes me happy so it's it's it's the even interesting to to think about the effects the potential effects that you bi could have on say intellectual property itself - is it if you no longer need to to hold on to intellectual property - would it be a important to have say you know lifetime Plus 70 years of intellectual property protection via copyright I don't think that makes any sense at all I think that a copyright made a lot more sense we first started it when say you got basically a 15 year head start you know
1:01:46you've got a monopoly on something for 15 years and then it went into the public domain I think that I think that we're all were Soph by excluding things from the public domain for such a long period of time even just look at Disney himself which is its own interesting story that that Walt Disney started any he all these stories were from the public domain and then so but now his stories are not in the public domain those are all Disney stories and no one can touch them no one can do anything about them and they they've even lobbied to maintain and extend copyrights over and over again
1:02:26and I think that that I think that's bad for all of us we the public domain is a rich thing you know the more that people are able to reach into a a common pool of ideas and play with those ideas and combine them then everybody is better off if you if you pull out an idea and monopolize it for a century I think that's worse for all all of humanity and so and another idea I think could be really interesting is to apply like the carbon tax model to intellectual property so what you would do is you would say you can monopolize something all you want to you you get
1:03:13your copyright you get your patent or whatever and but each year it gets more more expensive to keep it out of the public domain let's say you know just for simplicity sake you double it every year so the first year is like a dollar and then $2 and $4 and $8 and $16 so at first it's very affordable to maintain a monopoly on your patent or copyright but over time it gets more and more expensive so you know then it becomes a thousand dollars to keep it out of the public domain for a year then two thousand and four thousand and eight thousand sixteen thousand you know
1:03:46eventually yeah a million two million four million eight million and so eventually you reach a point where it's it's just too expensive to keep it on the public domain so it falls into the public domain so the whole time you've been actually encouraging people to let things go back to the public domain those who are paying for it to be excluded are actually paying everybody through the basic income because it's funding it I think that's I think that would be a really interesting idea to to fund this because it's just another one of those you know it's pros on both sides you can find the money from Disney
1:04:23tomorrow yeah yeah Mickey Mouse make them pay for it well we get a lot of a hundred and eighty billion yeah very guys know right I mean like with my podcast you know that obviously it's hard and so many people don't want to share my staff or whatever but I never put ads on my videos hope I haven't for how if I haven't done it deliberately and this kind of just free out there for everyone's to tune in and obviously I made my patreon account because I want people just kind of support what I'm doing because obviously I'd like to pay people to come on so I can have
1:05:06interesting guests that my followers want to see on etc but I think some people just want to hold on to their money it's hard you know yeah yeah so yeah so there's a couple things from that to that's really interesting is you're looking at like a scarcity mentality so you're right now people don't need to hold on to the money because they don't know what the future is going to to bring you know so it's more like this kind of hoarding mentality when you reduce that scarcity and you create like this concept of abundance and you're it's plenty and so like when I have a basic income having
1:05:45that I feel that that scarcity is not there and so I'm actually much more willing to donate to people than I was before because before basic income I didn't know oh you know a year down the road or whatever if I was going to need something but now I know that every month I'm gonna be okay so if I want to donate to somebody on patreon yeah I'm actually much more likely to do that now then I used to be and also looking at this I think that really shows the kind of the future of work too is that we shouldn't just think about you know the
1:06:20typical careers I think that was kind of like a temporary juncture in time where people started working 40 hours full-time for like decades at a time in the same place I think it's like a historical artifact before it wasn't like that it was actually more task labor before the industrialization happened and I think we're kind of going to go back to that where platforms like patreon enabled people to to do things like this where you can actually Rob podcast and that's valuable work and you you're doing something that you enjoy and other people enjoy and you're able to fund it through people who are providing you this extra base so imagine
1:07:04a future where you not only have a basic income but then you have your patreon you come to and other people have their patreon incomes and you know you're sharing it with each other and you're you're helping people do more than would otherwise be able to do you're not just sitting at home doing nothing you know you're you're able to do more and you're also able to earn more through what you're doing yeah and give to other people because if I had like a shot be pledging money to to other people whereas if someone's wants $5 a month I get what you mean that's this that scarcity that kind of kicks in can i
1:07:46really afford to spend $2 $5 on something yeah spend a tenner you know you know also this reminds me there's a really interesting result that I came across - and this is just so this goes back after the engagement and it ties what we're talking about here is that it was they found that those who are less engaged in their work or are see less giving they're less likely to donate to causes than those who are engaged by their work so then then you're not looking at like this amount of money that they have it's basically like how happy they are as like to kind of their
1:08:25daily living if you are engaged by your work then you're living in existence that's that's less upset angry and that you're more likely to give to other people and so again those kind of combined together where it just makes sense that you know in the future when you have a basic income when you've reduced scarcity when people have enough to start with then you're just you're more giving you're you're connecting to other people there's more empathy if there's more trust in society know it makes sense from like a psychological aspect you're happy to be cut to work and you plan on doing that work for a long time you've got the spare it's kind
1:09:06of seen as spare money because you're enjoying what you're doing is so yeah you know I'll be happy to go to work tomorrow whereas if you don't enjoy your job you're like oh maybe I'll just put a sick day and not go and whatever so no I mean it's been we've been talking for an hour and 10 minutes and it's been an absolute pleasure obviously I only booked you in for an hour but you've answered all my questions and I really appreciate yeah that's the five mind really opened my mind they're great to the aspects but I'll talk to you off camera anyways if you wanna you can promote yourself now this
1:09:40is your couple of minutes promote your websites and stuff but but I'll put them in the link below anyways but yeah yeah yeah so you know I have got a blog I actually have a frequently asked questions site that really gets into a lot of aspects so base can come that have you both discussed here and have gotten a undiscussed so that's Scott sands calm and my patreon account does patreon.com slash Scott's Anton's and I also just recommend going to the subreddit so that's a reddit.com slash are slash basic income if you want to learn more there's new stuff posted there every day to to really get into this and also
1:10:23basic income org which is a great resource to learn it's a news site that you can learn about what what's going on all over the world about you know basic income developments perfect well we'll talk off-camera anyways thank you for coming on really appreciate it alright thank you yeah and I'll roll the end credits cool [Music] you
Watch next
Dr Tom Walters on Pain, Rehab and Moving Better
Phil Daru on Leadership, Building a Gym Business and Coaching Athletes
Phil Daru on Mobility, Movement Assessment and Coaching Other Coaches
Phil Daru on Launching a Podcast, Weight Cutting and Building an Audience
Phil Daru on Preparing Dustin Poirier for Khabib and Mentoring Coaches
Oliver Wells on Stoicism, Young Men and Finding Direction at 19
Phil Daru on Coaching Dustin Poirier, Fight Camp and Programming
Dr Paulie on Deliberate Coaching, Behaviour Science and His Book
Rob Solly on Personal Training in London and Training Out of a Rucksack
Coach Dave on Training Pro Athletes, Fighters and 20 Years of Coaching