The short answer
Starting boxing as a beginner means accepting you will get hit and you will never have every answer. Stefi Cohen told me on The JB Podcast that boxing is more like poker than chess, and Jake Bostwick told me staying calm under fire comes from practice and time. Stefi also told me which comments still got to her.
In this post
Nobody is good at something the first time. The hard part is what you do after you find that out, because that is where most people quietly stop.
I found out with boxing. The one time I went sparring, I did one round of three minutes with a mouthpiece in, and I was gassed. Someone who had been boxing for 12 or 13 years had told me it was hard, and I still came out thinking, this is a lot harder than it looks. I gave the guy a little dig to the stomach, moved my head, and he caught me with a good shot. I saw a few stars. I didn't go back. I went and did jiu jitsu instead.
So when I sat down with Stefi Cohen and Jake "Brutal" Bostwick on The JB Podcast, I wanted to know what keeps a beginner going after that first round. Stefi is a doctor of physical therapy and a powerlifter who has set 25 world records. At the time we recorded, she was about eight months into boxing. Jake fights bare knuckle in BKFC, and he was helping coach her.
The episode went up in April 2021, so everything here is from around then. Stefi had her first pro fight a couple of months later, on 4 June 2021, and won it by TKO. You can watch the whole conversation on Stefi's guest page.
What stuck with me was how honest Stefi was about being a beginner, and how much of what they both said works for anything hard you are starting.
What is it like to start boxing as a beginner?
Starting boxing as a beginner, the way Stefi Cohen described it to me, means a lot of training and a lot of ground to cover. At the time we recorded, she was training six or seven days a week, sparring three or four times a week and doing mitt work almost every day, because she was still learning the movements.
She didn't talk about finding time for it. She told me it's a matter of making sure the training gets done and then "organizing my day around that and not the other way around".
Her coach used what she called an outside in approach. First he got her comfortable on the outside. That meant learning to defend, moving round the ring when someone is chasing you, not getting caught on the ropes and getting out if you do, and measuring her reach.
When we spoke, she was moving into the next stage, which was learning to come in and stay in the pocket. That is where it gets real, because as she put it:
"You are gonna get hit. It's not a matter of like if you're gonna get hit."
Jake put it in perspective. He told me he had been fighting since he was 16 and was 31, while she had been at it for about eight months. He also said her style was "literally a mini me", which I think is a big compliment coming from him.
What I take from it is that you don't start where the experienced people are. You start on the outside, learn to protect yourself, and step in a bit closer when you're ready.
Is boxing more like chess or poker?
Boxing is more like poker than chess, according to Stefi Cohen. She told me she has a very analytical mind, almost too literal, and she tries to build every scenario in her head: if this happens, then I do that.
"I find it funny when people compare boxing to chess ... because I don't think it's that predictable ... I would compare it more to poker."
She called it "a probability game". The problem with a mind like hers, she said, is that it wants the full plan before it moves. Her coach would teach her a jab, jab, cross and then a weave to the right, and she would get stuck doing only that. She found it really hard to create her own combinations or her own openings.
She was honest that "i'll never have all of the answers and that bothers me". If you overthink, you will know that feeling. You want every answer before you start, so you never start.
A poker player never knows the next card. They play what is most likely and adjust. You can do the same with a new class or a hard conversation: make the best move you can, then respond to what actually happens.
What happens the first time you spar?
The first time you spar goes one of two ways, Stefi Cohen told me, and she used my story as the example. Either you thrive off the adrenaline of getting hit, or you get punched in the face and decide you don't need to be doing this. I was clearly the second one.
Stefi was the first one. She told me she knew she was a fighter the first time she ever sparred, when she got clocked right in the middle of the face. She felt the adrenaline and the fire of it, felt powered for the rest of the session, and loved it.
Her toughest session came the first time she sparred outside her own gym, at a place in Miami called Sweatbox. She told me a lot of the best women train there, including USA Boxing team members and unbeaten pros. They put her in with a southpaw, which she had never sparred before.
She assumed the coach would tell his fighter to take it easy on a beginner. She learned that "there's no such thing as taking it easy". The girl landed the stiffest jabs Stefi had ever felt, all in the exact same spot, for the whole session.
"And I liked it, like I wouldn't flinch out, had like a complete poker face."
Her coach told her afterwards that he was impressed, because he thought she would give up or ask them to stop.
Jake was even more blunt. "I genuinely enjoy getting hit in the face," he told me. He grew up around fighting in London and worked the doors from about 18 or 19 until he was around 24, fighting every weekend. "It's legit part of my nature," he said. When someone catches him in sparring, he smiles.
Stefi's view was that you either have it or you don't. I'm not sure I'd go that far for everything in life. I didn't have it for boxing, and I went and found jiu jitsu instead. Not liking one hard thing doesn't mean you can't do hard things. It might just mean that one isn't yours.
Can you learn to stay calm when you get hit?
You can learn to stay calm when you get hit, and Jake Bostwick told me it is something you build over time. I asked because I'm the opposite. When I get hit, I just want to take someone down and choke them.
Jake told me that when Stefi got hit, she would think about it, and there would be a little delay, whereas he would just carry on.
"That just comes with practice ... regular work and consistency."
He didn't pretend he had always been that way. He told me there had been times he screamed in sparring and tried to knock people out. In the couple of months before we recorded, he had pumped the brakes and worked on controlling that aggression, which he called "controlled violence".
Stefi had her own story. Right at the start, she was sparring her boyfriend after a silly argument earlier that day. He caught her right on the mouth, it hurt badly, and she kicked him in the stomach as hard as she could.
What I take from both of them is that the way you react now is not the way you have to react forever. Calm is a rep, the same as a jab. You get it by turning up and practising, not by waiting until you feel calm.
If you want something to practise on, the free 30 day plan sets out small, clear steps for each day, so you're building the habit even on the days you don't feel like it.
How do you deal with negative comments when you're new at something?
Stefi Cohen deals with negative comments by reminding herself that her brain is wired to make them feel bigger than they are. She told me she has been in the public eye for so long that it's very hard to offend her now, but early on she used to get really worked up.
The way she explained it, our brains take note of anything negative as a way of protecting us. She compared it to getting bitten by a snake on a hike, so the next time a branch touches your leg, you jump. She said she learned this from a book by Ben Bergeron, a CrossFit coach.
"Those comments don't have more weight, don't matter more ... and shouldn't bother me as much as I'm making them."
That doesn't mean nothing got through. Stefi was honest with me about the comments that still bothered her at the time.
"My biggest insecurity now is like what my boxing looks like ... whether or not I can, I can be really good at it."
She told me it bothered her when people said she wasn't a boxer, that she was doing it for the wrong reasons or for attention, or that she wasn't really committed. Jake's answer was that those people had no clue, and that he had seen her hitting the pads. On his own page, he told me he just deletes a comment he thinks will start bad chat and ignores them.
Stefi also talked about judging from the outside. She mentioned a book called Thinking in Bets and an idea she called resulting, where people explain a whole outcome with one thing. Her point was that there is never just one thing, and that the people judging are not the ones doing the work.
"Ultimately it's you that's inside there ... here in the gym training when nobody's watching ... suffering, that's getting frustrated, that's crying."
That is true for anyone who is new at something. The people laughing at your first class are not the ones doing the work.
Why strict diets don't last, according to Stefi Cohen
Strict diets don't last, Stefi Cohen told me, because they fight your lifestyle instead of fitting it. She picks an eating style that is in line with how she lives "and not the other way around", and her first goal is eating in a way that lets her train as hard as she needs to.
Jake was in the middle of that change when we recorded. He told me he'd had a mad food obsession since he was young, and that he was slowly drifting away from it. He was fighting at 77 kilos, and he called it a lifestyle change. Stefi told me it made her really happy to hear him say that.
"That change in mindset from being overly restrictive to ... being able to adopt a more flexible style of dieting ... is exactly what leads to long term results."
Her example stuck with me. Jake was at a petrol station about to grab a protein bar that tasted just like a Snickers. Stefi asked him why he didn't just have the Snickers, which was what he actually wanted, with a scoop of protein powder. Her advice was to go and have the chocolate bar and look at the calories.
I'm not giving you a diet here. If food is a struggle, talk to a qualified professional. What I take from Stefi and Jake is the mindset: a plan you can keep beats a perfect plan you quit in a fortnight.
One thing you can do today to get started
One thing you can do today is the first round of whatever you have been putting off. Book the class, go to the session, or try the thing you think you'll be bad at. Expect it to be a lot harder than it looks, because it was for me.
Then do what Stefi's coach did with her and start on the outside. You don't need to step straight into the pocket. Learn the basics, protect yourself, and step in a little closer each week.
When someone has something to say about it, remember Stefi's question about the people on the outside: "what would they do if they were here".
Stefi told me her own goal is "always a moving target". Yours can be too. You just have to start.
If you want a bit of structure after today, the 30 day plan is free. There are more fighters I've spoken to on the guests page, and more like this on the blog.
What to take from this
- Expect to get hit when you start boxing, because Stefi Cohen told me it is not a matter of if.
- Learn to defend and move on the outside first, then work your way into the pocket, the way Stefi Cohen's coach taught her.
- Stop waiting to have every answer before you act, because Stefi Cohen compares boxing to poker, a game of probabilities, rather than chess.
- Treat staying calm as a skill you build, because Jake Bostwick told me it comes with practice, time and consistency.
- When a negative comment gets to you, remember that Stefi Cohen believes your brain is wired to make it feel bigger than it is.
Questions people ask
How often does Stefi Cohen train for boxing?
When we recorded in 2021, Stefi Cohen told me she trained six or seven days a week, sparred three or four times a week and did mitt work almost every day. She said she makes sure the training gets done and organises her day around it.
Did Stefi Cohen win her first pro boxing fight?
Yes. Stefi Cohen won her pro boxing debut by TKO on 4 June 2021 in the Dominican Republic, a couple of months after our JB Podcast conversation went up in April 2021.
Is boxing more like chess or poker?
Stefi Cohen told me she doesn't think boxing is like chess, because it isn't that predictable. She compares boxing to poker, a probability game where you respond to what is most likely to happen.
How do you stay calm when you get hit in boxing?
Jake Bostwick told me that staying calm when you get hit comes with practice, time, regular work and consistency. At the time we recorded, he had spent the previous couple of months working on what he called controlled violence.
How does Stefi Cohen deal with negative comments?
Stefi Cohen told me she reminds herself that our brains are wired to give negative comments more weight than they deserve. She was honest that comments saying she wasn't a real boxer still bothered her at the time we recorded.
Who is Jake Bostwick?
Jake 'Brutal' Bostwick is a bare knuckle fighter who competes in BKFC. When we recorded in 2021 he was 31, had been fighting since he was 16, and was helping coach Stefi Cohen in boxing.
Did this one land?
Read next
From the conversationsHow to Calm Your Nerves Before Something Big: Joseph HolmesHow to calm your nerves before something big. Former UFC fighter Joseph Holmes told me how box breathing and one reminder keep him steady.
From the conversationsHow to Perform Under Pressure: Rani Yahya on Using FearHow to perform under pressure. UFC veteran Rani Yahya told me to embrace fear, step back from your thoughts and feel grateful before you start.
From the conversationsHow to Control Nerves Under Pressure: Olympian Harry HepworthHow to control nerves under pressure. Olympic medallist Harry Hepworth told me how he uses his nerves and moves on fast after a bad routine.


